Here is the Texans’ record with various combinations of Matt Schaub and Andre Johnson (including their playoff win over the Bengals):
- Both players: 3-1
- Johnson, no Schaub: 3-1
- Schaub, no Johnson: 4-2
- Neither player: 1-2
So, that means they are 6-2 with Johnson and 5-4 without him. They are 7-3 with Schaub, and 4-3 without him. The numbers are slightly better for Johnson (and worse for Schaub) if I exclude the Texans’ meaningless week 17 game against the Titans. The Texans were at their worst (1-2) when neither guy played, but they haven’t lost a meaningful game with Johnson and without Schaub. I still think the Ravens will win on Sunday, but this game should be close.