As the college football season gets under way, my buddy Jeff and I put together a brand new college football ranking for ESPN the Magazine (insider required, in print 9/17/2012). We started with ESPN’s pro franchise ultimate standings as a template, and tried to make things as quantitative as we could to make the ranking defensible. We’ve inspired some feedback already. The SEC does well of course but didn’t land the number one team — check it out if you get the chance!
Tyler Williams
-
Join 42 other subscribers
-
Recent Posts
Categories
- Baseball (22)
- Basketball (75)
- Book Reviews (1)
- Causal Analysis (22)
- College Sports (28)
- Commentary (62)
- Common Sense (53)
- Financial Analysis (17)
- Football (73)
- Gambling (7)
- Hockey (16)
- Humor (13)
- Innovative Ideas (32)
- LOS LIIINNNKKKSSS!!! (7)
- Other Sports (11)
- Pop Culture (13)
- Prediction (17)
- Probability Analysis (24)
- Research Papers (11)
- Riddles (4)
- Rugby (3)
- Rules Analysis (25)
- Science (4)
- Soccer (8)
- Sports Stats (19)
- Trades/Free Agency (18)
- Uncategorized (7)
Archives
- Adrian the Canadian Baltimore Ravens baseball basketball basketball game simulations Boston Celtics causal analysis Chicago Bears Chicago Bulls Cincinnati Bengals college football Conor Williams Denver Broncos Detroit Lions Detroit Tigers do teams tank NBA draft position Dwight Howard Eli Manning ESPN Florida football Golden State Warriors Green Bay Packers hockey Houston Texans how much tanking is there in the NBA Indianapolis Colts Kansas Kentucky Kobe Bryant Los Angeles Lakers Miami Dolphins Michigan Minnesota Timberwolves Minnesota Vikings MLB National Basketball Association National Football League National Hockey League NBA NBA draft lottery NBA draft lottery incentive to tank nba teams NCAA Men's Division I Basketball Championship NCAA tournament simulations New England Patriots New Jersey Nets New Orleans Hornets New Orleans Saints New York Giants NFL NFL rule book NHL Oakland Raiders Orlando Magic Peyton Manning Philadelphia Eagles Pittsburgh Steelers playoffs Ray Allen San Francisco 49ers Seattle Seahawks Sloan Sports Analytics Conference soccer Sports Super Bowl tanking Teamrankings Tim Tebow Tom Brady Tony True Wins Washington Redskins Washington Wizards
How much money are college football players worth?
A few months ago, my friend Jeff and I worked out how much University of Florida athletes are worth to the school for ESPN the Magazine. The key to our approach — in contrast to other studies — is that we looked at profits generated by each player, rather than revenue. Revenue is not so relevant if it is outrun by costs. What matters is profit (before subtracting player compensation). Profit tells you how much schools could actually pay their players.
The numbers at Florida
The short answer: the best college football players at Florida are worth millions per year, the best basketball players are worth a few hundred thousand, and all other athletes cost the school quite a bit of money. If you have ESPN insider, you can view the full article online. How much of this profit do football and basketball players see? Very little. Player compensation in the form of scholarships is between $15,000 and $50,000 per year per player at most schools. By contrast, other athletes are getting a great deal. Not only do they get a free education, but Florida spends tens of thousands more on each player to ensure that they have awesome coaching, facilities, and equipment.
Football profits across the FBS
Today, Jeff and I have a related project at ESPN, which will also appear in ESPN the Mag soon. We argue that college football players should be paid. Why? Average profit generated by FBS football players — before scholarships — is about $164,000. The average scholarship payout is just $27,000 by our estimation. So, “non-profit” schools are making an average of $137,000 in profit per player. And if that’s not enough, look at the breakdown by conference (all numbers are from the U.S. Department of Education for the 2010-2011 season):
The SEC and Big Ten are making over $300,000 per player! It’s no wonder we see recruiting scandals every year. They won’t disappear until schools are allowed to pay players closer to what they are worth.
For the curious, here’s the top 10:
Paying players is the right move
We thought about the arguments against paying Continue reading →
2 Comments
Posted in College Sports, Commentary, Common Sense, Financial Analysis, Football, Innovative Ideas
Tagged $2 million, Andrew Zimbalist, average scholarship value, basketball players, college football, college football costs, college football parity, college football players, College Football Premier League, college football profits, college football revenues, college football scholarships, Division I (NCAA), ESPN, ESPN debate, espn insider, ESPN the Mag, ESPN The Magazine, FBS football, FBS football revenue, Florida, football, Great Debate issue ESPN the Mag, how much are college athletes worth, how much is a college education worth, how much is a scholarship worth, Jeff Phillips, Jeffrey Phillips, Patrick Rishe, Patrick Rishe Forbes, paying college athletes, paying college football players, should college football players be paid, Sports, Texas, Texas football revenue, Tyler Williams, Tyler Williams ESPN, USA Today, value of a college education, value of a scholarship, which college football team makes the most money